Chart Supplement 12/25/2024
San Gabriel Valley Airport Association:
-
Location: 4233 Santa Anita Ave, El Monte, CA, 91731, California
-
Followers: 181
-
Agency: NON_PROFIT
- Meetings are held on the third Wednesday of every month January through November. Airport Terminal - 7 p.m.
- San Gabriel Valley Airport - Porsche Display 8 am-10 am - San Gabriel Valley Airport, 4233 Santa Anita Ave,El Monte,CA,United States
News & Challenges:
06/01/2025 Report: Aviation Commission 5/28/2025 meeting held at KEMT Reported by J. Marc Haney DDS. MS. James Miller contributed to this review.
The meeting was poorly attended, though airport advocate luminary and former KWHP airport manager, James Miller was present and addressed the commissioners. Mr. Miller mentioned to the Commission that Supervisor Horvath’s direction to not take money from the FAA is contributing to Whiteman Airport’s detracting condition, which the County is obligated to repair.
Additionally, Mr. Miller discussed a new $29 Million study by the California Air Resources Board concerning air pollution in the greater Los Angeles and San Francisco areas. The study is tied to Pacoima Beautiful as the “community” component and is specifically targeting Whiteman and Van Nuys Airports. It will also be studying air quality around Compton and San Gabriel Valley airports. See Aclima.earth and our site's Whiteman Airport page for more details.
Dr Haney also addressed the Commission concerning the fact the rent study failed to properly address non-aviation hangar use rents. The study did not compare similar off-airport rents for similar facilities, instead using personal storage units not exceeding 400sq feet. Hangars start at 840 sq feet and go up to over 2000 Sq feet.
Appointed by Supervisor Hilda Solis, a new commissioner was introduced. Mr. Singh is an investor banker and is engaged in the motel hospitality business. Commissioner Signh is welcomed as a good addition to the Commission. He seems willing to address the need to improve revenue without unduly burdening the current tenants.
05/25/2025 LOS ANGELES COUNTY AVIATION COMMISSION AGENDA MEETING MAY 28, 2025 7 p.m.
5/20/2025 Re: HANGARS or HANG UP? (the history of a public records request)
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez <AlCruz@dpw.lacounty.gov>
Date: May 14, 2025 at 4:41:22 PM PDT
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>, "W. Eric Pilsk" <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>, Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: RE: Public Records Act Request 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesTo J.M. Haney
EXTENSION IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received on December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
This Public Records Inspection/Copying Request involves “Unusual Circumstances” which means the following selected situation(s):
¨The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request.
¨The need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request.
þThe need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, with another agency having substantial interest in the determination of the request or among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.
¨The need to compile data, to write programming language or a computer program, or to construct a computer report to extract data.
Los Angeles County Public Works is actively working on your request and will require additional time to search for and collect responsive records. Therefore, we will contact you with an update by June 17, 2025.
Please note our business hours are Monday-Thursday from 7 am – 5 pm. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Tuesday, April 15, 2025 3:33 PM
To: 'Marc Haney' <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; 'W. Eric Pilsk' <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: Public Records Act Request 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesTo J.M. Haney:
RESPONSE IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
We have located the following documents responsive to your request:
- Facility Use Agreement
- Email Records
We will continue to review our files for additional responsive records to your public records request and will provide you with an update on our continuing review on or before May 14, 2025.
Please note that the California Public Records Act does not require public agencies to answer questions, but rather requires the production of non-exempt public records, as defined by law. Accordingly, Public Works reviews inquiries to determine if there are non-exempt records that are responsive. Non-exempt records identified in response to that inquiry are provided. Any exemptions will be noted in our response above.
Please contact me should you have any questions.
Thank you,
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:18 AM
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: RE: 14-Day Extension 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesTo J.M. Haney
EXTENSION IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received on December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
This Public Records Inspection/Copying Request involves “Unusual Circumstances” which means the following selected situation(s):
þ The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request.
þThe need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request.
þThe need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, with another agency having substantial interest in the determination of the request or among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.
¨The need to compile data, to write programming language or a computer program, or to construct a computer report to extract data.
Los Angeles County Public Works is actively working on your request and will require additional time to search for and collect responsive records. Therefore, we will contact you with an update by April 15, 2025.
Please note our business hours are Monday-Thursday from 7 am – 5 pm. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Thursday, February 13, 2025 10:22 AM
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: RE: 14-Day Extension 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesTo J.M. Haney
EXTENSION IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received on December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
This Public Records Inspection/Copying Request involves “Unusual Circumstances” which means the following selected situation(s):
þ The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request.
þThe need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request.
þThe need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, with another agency having substantial interest in the determination of the request or among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.
¨The need to compile data, to write programming language or a computer program, or to construct a computer report to extract data.
Los Angeles County Public Works is actively working on your request and will require additional time to search for and collect responsive records. Therefore, we will contact you with an update by March 12, 2025.
Please note our business hours are Monday-Thursday from 7 am – 5 pm. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Thursday, January 16, 2025 2:12 PM
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: RE: 14-Day Extension 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesTo J.M. Haney / Marc Haney:
EXTENSION IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received on December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
This Public Records Inspection/Copying Request involves “Unusual Circumstances” which means the following selected situation(s):
þ The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request.
þThe need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request.
þThe need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, with another agency having substantial interest in the determination of the request or among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.
¨The need to compile data, to write programming language or a computer program, or to construct a computer report to extract data.
Los Angeles County Public Works is actively working on your request and will require additional time to search for and collect responsive records. Therefore, we will contact you with an update by February 13, 2025.
Please note our business hours are Monday-Thursday from 7 am – 5 pm. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Thursday, December 26, 2024 11:08 AM
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: RE: 14-Day Extension 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesTo J.M. Haney / Marc Haney:
EXTENSION IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received on December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020, Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8, 2024, AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
This Public Records Inspection/Copying Request involves “Unusual Circumstances” which means the following selected situation(s):
þ The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request.
þThe need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request.
þThe need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, with another agency having substantial interest in the determination of the request or among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.
¨The need to compile data, to write programming language or a computer program, or to construct a computer report to extract data.
Los Angeles County Public Works is actively working on your request and will require additional time to search for and collect responsive records. Therefore, we will contact you with an update by January 16, 2025.
Please note our business hours are Monday-Thursday from 7 am – 5 pm. Our offices will be closed on December 25, 2024, for Christmas and January 1, 2025, for New Year’s Day. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Thursday, December 12, 2024 9:34 AM
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: 14-Day Extension 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesACKNOWLEDGEMENT INVOKING A 14-DAY EXTENSION IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR PUBLIC RECORDS ACT REQUEST OUR FILE NUMBER 6050
We have reviewed your Public Records Act Request received on December 3, 2024, wherein you requested:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
This Public Records Inspection/Copying Request involves “Unusual Circumstances” which means the following selected situation(s):
þ The need to search for and collect the requested records from field facilities or other establishments that are separate from the office processing the request.
¨The need to search for, collect, and appropriately examine a voluminous amount of separate and distinct records that are demanded in a single request.
þThe need for consultation, which shall be conducted with all practicable speed, with another agency having substantial interest in the determination of the request or among two or more components of the agency having substantial subject matter interest therein.
¨The need to compile data, to write programming language or a computer program, or to construct a computer report to extract data.
Under these “Unusual Circumstances”, which apply only to the extent reasonably necessary to the proper processing of the particular request, the Government Code provides the responder with a 14-day extension time-period to process the request. Therefore, we will contact you with an update by December 26, 2024.
Our offices will be closed on December 25, 2024, for Christmas and January 1, 2025, for New Year’s Day. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Sent: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 11:17 AM
To: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: Acknowledgment 6050 - AMCG Airport Rent StudiesThis email is to acknowledge the receipt of the subject request on December 3, 2024. The Public Records Act allows for an initial statutory 10-days response period from the date of receipt of the request (and a subsequent 14-days extension if necessary). The initial statutory 10-day response period for your request begins on December 3, 2024, and you will receive an update concerning the status of your request by December 12, 2024.
Please note our business hours are Monday-Thursday from 7 am – 5 pm. Thank you.
Alicia Cruz-Gonzalez
Investigator I
Los Angeles County Public Works(626) 458-7091
________________________________________________________________________
From: Marc Haney <haney@haneyperio.com>
Sent: Tuesday, December 3, 2024 9:20 AM
To: PW-PWPRRS <PWPRRS@pw.lacounty.gov>
Cc: Paul Maselbas <pmaselbas@dpw.lacounty.gov>; W. Eric Pilsk <epilsk@kaplankirsch.com>; Warren Wellen <wwellen@counsel.lacounty.gov>
Subject: Public records request: AMCG rent Studies performed for Los Angeles county regarding the five county owned airports. .Los Angeles County, Department of Public Works, Mark Pastrella
We request the following records be produced:
- The RFP for contracting with AMCG for the AMCG Feb. 7, 2020 Airport Rent Study.
- All communications between Los Angeles County and AMCG regarding the Feb.7, 2020 AMCG Airport Rent Study, the Feb. 8 2024 AMCG Aeronautic Airport Rent Study, and the Feb. 8, 2024 AMCG Non-Aeronautic Rent Study.
The request includes all forms of communication such as email, text, facsimile, paper, mail or other communications between then division Chief Richard Smith, assistant Chief Jason Morgan, current administrator, Paul Malesbas, and any and all other County representatives and their agents who were involved with the rent studies.
Records can be emailed to the address above, or mailed to: J.M.Haney
4/15/2025 On today's BOS Meeting - Item #27 - Aircraft Storage Hangar Lease Agreement:
03/17/2025 Users at KEMT filed a Part 16 Complaint against the county for:
1. Charging under fair market value rental rates to tenants using hangars for public storage and businesses and charging above market competitive rates for aeronautical tenants. Of 1,089 hangars under LAC ownership and management, 264 have no aviation demand, of which 137 are currently being used for public storage.
2. The current Aviation Division director has announced his retirement, stating his last day will be in two weeks.
3. LAC conducted rent studies published in 2024 under the current Aviation Division director and plans to increase hangar rates based on these studies. However, the study results show that LAC already is charging above market competitive rates yet proposes to increase rents between 5 to 50 % depending on hangar type, at KEMT. The rent increase is justified in order to meet projected budget needs five years from now. This while 24% of county hangars lack aviation demand, and all other competitive airports cited in the study are 100% occupied with aviation, have waitlist, and do not allow non aeronautical use of hangars. Increasing LAC rate far above market competitive rates will most likely increase hangar vacancies, thereby reducing aviation demand and use of federally funded airports.
It is highly recommended that hangar tenants of LAC airports review the 2024 AMCG Aeronautical Rent Study to see how much the county plans to increase their rent.
The study has severe design flaws, especially where AMCG recommends higher rent increases ranging from 5 to 50% over what its own study results show to be competitive and comparable in the marketplace. The FAA is reviewing the methods and conclusions of this study, brought to light by KEMT users.
Finally, the Aviation Division recommended at last month’s commission meeting to outsource fuel dispensing. The reason being that the county can not afford to dispense fuel. This is due in large part because the Aviation Division must pay the county procurement office 94 cents per gallon to process the paperwork. Hmmm. The county does not warehouse or handle the fuel as it is dispensed directly to the airports upon ordering. A 94 cent per gallon processing fee is excessive and kills the county’s ability to provide marketplace competitive fuel prices.
At KEMT, the self-serve fuel pump as operated for a total of 6 weeks over the past two years. The county is not motivated to repair the system. The local FBO has had a monopoly on fuel dispensing charging well above surrounding airports. - Marc Haney D.D.S. MS
01/22/2025 HANGAR RENTALS at LA County Airports -
01/05/2025 - Los Angeles County plans to increase aviation hangar rates as much as 50%, while maintaining a 24% aviation hangar vacancy rate”
“Two KEMT hangar tenants, on behalf of 42 tenant petition signers, filed a Part 16 formal complaint against LAC alleging the county has habitually charged higher rents for aviation tenants and below fair market value rents for hangars being used for public storage. The county has responded, and complainants have 45 days to rebut.
LAC owns and manages 1089 aircraft hangars, 137 are currently being used for public storage, and 126 remain vacant, without demand. This phenomenon of 76% of hangars being used for aviation purposes is unique to Los Angeles County. No other single airport or multiple airport system managed by a single sponsor in the nation has this high a hangar vacancy problem. All surrounding airports in the So Cal region are full and have wait lists for hangar rental.
LAC’s recent hangar appraisal study confirms the Part 16 Complaint: All hangar types in the study were priced at higher rental rates than comparable or similar and competitive hangar types. The complaint brings up two FAA grant assurance violation issues.
- 1. LAC fails to offer its five county-owned airports to the public as airports fairly and reasonably, without discrimination.
- 2. The county fails to meet the self-sustainability rules by charging below fair market value rents for non-aviation hangar tenants using aeronautic hangars for public storage AND failing to market empty hangars for aviation and non-aviation rental income.
Tenants at KEMT, KPOC, KWHP, and KCPM are encouraged to review the ACMG 2024 Aeronautic Rent Study for the proposed rent increases that range from 4% to 50 % and begin July 2025. The study can be accessed on the County’s Aviation Division website. Visit that page Here.
Any questions can be directed to Haney@haneyperio.com”
October 2024 - Hangars - Rise in Costs imposed by the County have been cause for significant concern. An initial filing was rejected because of a technical error. The following is the resubmitted version. The results are expected now (December 2024) but, may take a bit longer to be posted.
EMT Hangar Issue Revised filed
Related Reference Material:
Feb. 8, 2024 - Aeronautical Rent Study Update for San Gabriel Valley Airport produced by the LA County Dept. of Public Works.
Frequently Asked Questions & Answers On FAA Policy on Use of …
Aug 1, 2022 · "The sponsor must charge a fair market commercial rental rate for any hangar rental or use for non-aeronautical purposes. However, aeronautical use must receive priority consideration and accommodation over non-aeronautical use, even if the rental rate would be …"