Open Letter to LA County DPW – San Gabriel Valley Airport Hangars – Serious Safety Problem

To: LA County PW

 

To whom it May Concern:

 

I speak on behalf of numerous KEMT hangar tenants.  There are some concerns regarding the County’s attempt to pass the burden of maintaining the County owned hangar structures to the tenants that have only month-to-month license agreements, and who use the County’s hangar facilities for storing aircraft.

Contrary to the old agreements with American Airport Corporation; some still in effect, the new hanger license agreements require the tenant to inspect the hangar unit and accept the hangar "as is" as of the date of signing the contract agreement.  However, there is no specific language that the month-to-month hangar tenant is required to provide repairs and maintenance to the County facilities, such as a leaking roof, accept in cases where the tenant causes the damage.

In my case, the roof did not leak when I signed my contract, nor did it leak in subsequent rainstorms.  However, water streaming onto my light switch and electrical outlet is a new event due to the recent rains and the progressive failure of the roof structure to prevent water intrusion.  The exact same condition applies to a nearby hangar. In that case, water began dripping onto a classic aircraft, as well as onto the entry light switch/electrical outlet.

Consequently, I would like to suggest  that comments made by LA COUNTY PW that infers my license agreement relieves the County of structural maintenance obligations is misguided. Nowhere does the contract state that a month-to-month licensee is responsible for structural repairs due to a decline in facility due to poor construction, old age, non-tenant related criminal behavior, or an act of God.

Other LAC commercial leases explicitly state where the long-term commercial tenant might be responsible for maintaining the structure, such as tenants with ground leases. But for month-to-month license tenants, the idea that the tenant is responsible for maintaining the County’s property, while the County retains complete control over repairs and maintenance (as stated in the license agreements) is an over-reach, and would place undue burden on the tenant.  The month-to-month licensee tenants do not own a leasehold and thereby lack control over the ownership of the hangar structure.

Additionally, hangar tenants pay a Possessory Interest Tax for use of the hangar, as well as a property tax on their aircraft. I would like to further address the PI tax and the liability issues:

  • Valuation & Improvements: As noted by the Napa County Assessor's Office, a PI tax is assessed solely on the market value of the right to possess the land and improvements for that anticipated term. If a hangar's roof fails and renders the space unusable or degraded, the actual market value of that possessory right drops—which is grounds for an assessment appeal with the Los Angeles County Assessment Appeals Board

Why Structural & Roof Repairs Belong to the County

In standard County-owned T-hangar or box hangar agreements (managed by Los Angeles County Public Works), maintenance duties are strictly divided:

  • Lessor (County) Responsibility: Structural integrity (roof, walls, foundation), exterior surfaces, common ramps, and main hangar door tracks/frames.
  • Lessee (Tenant) Responsibility: Interior cleanliness, light bulbs, minor door lubrication, and damage caused by the tenant's own negligence.

Why shifting structural repairs to a month-to-month tenant might defy legal and financial logic:

  • Lack of Capital Amortization: In commercial real estate, structural maintenance is only shifted to a tenant under a long-term "Triple Net" (NNN) lease (typically 10 to 50 years under California Government Code § 50478), allowing the tenant time to amortize major capital repairs. Requiring a 30-day tenant to pay for a roof repair allows the County to accept a capital improvement and immediately terminate the lease the following month.
  • Prohibition on Structural Alterations: Standard airport leases strictly forbid tenants from penetrating the roof or making structural modifications without written engineering approval and permits. A tenant cannot legally be held financially responsible for maintaining a structure they are barred from altering or repairing themselves.
  • Constructive Eviction & Habitability/Fitness: While residential "implied warranty of habitability" laws do not automatically apply to commercial hangars, California commercial lease law still recognizes constructive eviction and breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment. If a leaking roof damages an airworthy aircraft or prevents the hangar from being used for its sole permitted purpose (aircraft storage), the County is failing to deliver the contracted premises.

At San Gabriel Valley Airport (EMT), LA County Public Works (LADPW) perhaps cannot legally or logically trap a month-to-month tenant in a "catch-22" where the tenant is barred from repairing a structural roof leak yet forced to bear the financial or physical burden of the failure—especially when water intrusion into a live electrical switch creates an immediate fire and life-safety code violation.

Because the lease is direct with LADPW several distinct legal, regulatory, and contractual failures may be at play here.

  1. The Contractual "Catch-22" & Implied Covenant

While California commercial leases do not carry the residential "implied warranty of habitability" under California Civil Code § 1941, an "As-Is" clause only waives defects existing at the time the lease was signed (or visible upon inspection). I believe It does not absolve a landlord of structural maintenance when the contract simultaneously strips the tenant of the right to make repairs.

  • Impossible Performance: I believe under California contract law, if a landlord retains exclusive control over the exterior shell and roof—and explicitly prohibits the tenant from making structural repairs—the duty to maintain that roof remains with the landlord by necessity.
  • Breach of Quiet Enjoyment: I think under California Civil Code § 1927, every commercial lease carries an implied covenant of quiet enjoyment. When LADPW's failure to maintain a County-owned roof allows water to damage the hangars interior content or aircraft it might create an unsafe or costly circumstance.
  • The Electrical Hazard Overrides the Lease:

Water entering a wall-mounted electrical switch is no longer a simple maintenance dispute; it is an active California Electrical Code (CEC) and Fire Code violation on County-owned property, and I know that neither you nor I want that.

  • Non-Delegable Safety Duty: A public entity should not be able to use an "As-Is" clause to contract away its duty to abate an activhazard in a building it owns and controls.
  • Immediate Liability Exposure: I would like to suggest that as  the on-site management is now aware that water is entering an energized junction box or switch, that I am very thankful that LA COUNTY PW will quickly take action as the the circuit and the leaky roof exposes the County to premises liability should a fire destroy multiple aircraft in the hangar row.

Possessory Interest (PI) Tax Contradiction:

A major inconsistency in the County's position:

  • Taxed on Functional Value: The LA County Assessor taxes the tenant based on the fair market value of an intact, weather-tight aircraft hangar over an assumed multi-year term.
  • Calamity / Decline-in-Value Relief: My Goal is simply to have the hangar repaired. It is not my goal to see the County PW insist the hangar is "as-is" with a failing structure. No one wants to have to file an Assessment Appeal with the Los Angeles County Assessment Appeals Board for a Decline-in-Value (Prop 8) reduction, arguing the possessory interest has been impaired by unaddressed structural dilapidation.

FAA Grant Assurances (Sponsor Maintenance Obligations):

Because EMT is a federally obligated public-use airport, LA County might be bound by FAA Grant Assurance 19 (Operation and Maintenance).

  • Even if hangars are revenue-generating facilities rather than airfield pavement, the FAA requires airport sponsors to maintain airport facilities in a safe, serviceable condition and prohibits sponsors from letting revenue-producing aeronautical facilities deteriorate into safety hazards while collecting market-rate rents (which LADPW recently benchmarked in its EMT Aeronautical Airport Rent Study).

I respectfully request the county engage tenants who request repairs to failing County hangars and perform the necessary repairs in order to maintain serviceable hangar inventory.  I met with a County representative yesterday and was offered two items:

Item 1. Truly, I was offered to move and relocate to another hangar, however,  there is no other similar size hangar available.  Sat that moment I suggested doing so would prevent a revenue producing hangar from being leased. That wouldn’t be good.  I declined the offer as this would not be prudent real estate management, it would neither fix the problem, nor could I enjoy the same amenities of my current hangar, as is my goal.

Item 2. It was then offered to try and abate the water contact on the light switch/outlet.  I agreed and appreciated the proposed partial remedy.  However,  this does not abate the leaks in other areas of the hangar.

I  propose that the County provide a remedy to repair any leaking hangars upon the request of the affected tenants.  I am sure that no one, neither the County PW nor the tenants, want leaky roofs.

 

Thank you,

Marc Haney, DDS

Open Letter to Banning City Council re: 10/27/26 Airport Agenda Item 9.1

10/24/2026

====================================================================

CIVIC INFRASTRUCTURE ADVISORY BRIEF: RESOLUTION 2026-148  

====================================================================

 

ISSUED BY:   The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG)

DATE:  October 24, 2026

DISTRIBUTION:   Elizabeth Gibbs, City Manager; Art Vela, Public Works Director; and Honorable Members of the Banning City Council

 SUBJECT:  Independent Civic Advisory: Fiduciary, Public Safety, and Quality-of-Life Clarifications Regarding Proposed Resolution 2026-148 (Banning Municipal Airport Property)

====================================================================

Dear City Manager Gibbs, Public Works Director Vela, and Members of the City Council,

The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG), operates as an independent voluntary non-commercial regional aviation safety and advocacy platform drawing over 64,000 verified unique visitor logins last quarter, is submitting this formal correspondence for inclusion into the public record regarding **Resolution 2026-148** on your October 27, 2026, agenda.

As SCAUWG.org is confident that the Council only wants to act if you are positive you have all the available facts, and that you can best protect the City from a less than optimum path forward, we offer this polite opinion. It is submitted with the sincere desire to ensure that the Council has an opportunity to give these highly technical infrastructure, fiscal, and community health points full consideration, with the shared motivation to move forward with the most sustainable method for Banning’s future.

While staff’s report frames the proposed 55-year ground lease as an essential component to address the General Fund's long-term fiscal sustainability, we respectfully submit that the following five parameters introduce significant structural risks that warrant closer evaluation before the City enters into a binding pre-development agreement:

  1. Uncalculated Fair Market Value Repayment Caps under Section 756:
  1. Staff correctly notes that the FAA Reauthorization Act of 2024 provides a conditional pathway for federal release. However, Section 756 strictly mandates that before a release is granted, the City must repay the Fair Market Value of the specific 20 acres acquired under the 1983 FAA grant.
  1. Because the City is actively processing entitlements to rezone this 232-acre property for a 3.2-million-square-foot industrial warehouse layout, the FAA might possibly legally appraise those 20 acres at their "Highest and Best Use" as high-value industrial land—artificially inflating the city's upfront cash repayment penalties before a single brick is laid.
  1. Proceeding without locked-in, independent FAA appraisal numbers expose the General Fund to an unaudited capital liability.
  1. The Net-Zero Mechanics of the Public Benefit Fee: The term sheet features a $6 million Public Benefit Fee paid upon the initial lease takedown. However, the text explicitly details that this fee is completely offset by the costs incurred to close the airport, including the mandatory FAA closure repayments. This structure might represent a net-zero mechanism. This is because the initial developer fee could be entirely exhausted by clearing federal regulatory debt incurred by liquidating the runway, rather than injecting new, flexible capital into the city's current operating budget.
  1. The Permanent Forfeiture of Non-Reimbursable Federal Safety Grants: Moving to decommission the airport permanently terminates Banning's statutory access to regular federal AIP (Airport Improvement Program) funding and the massive infrastructure allocations under the BIL (Bipartisan Infrastructure Law). Rather than leveraging these guaranteed, non-reimbursable federal dollars to neutralize the Airport Fund's negative $561,023 structural variance, closing the runway forces local taxpayers to carry the long-term maintenance costs of the resulting industrial infrastructure out of a General Fund already managing multi-year operating pressures.
  1. Long-Term Option and Inflation Risk Exposure: Locking in a terminal purchase option floor of $33.625 million based on current 2026 un-escalated land values fix a static land price 55 years into the future, removing any hedge against inflation and capping the generational appreciation of a massive 232-acre municipal asset. Furthermore, the proposed $0.30 per square foot rental discount for the first five years of each phase represents a significant near-term revenue deferral during the exact window the City faces its most acute fiscal strain.
  1. The Surrender of the Airspace Safety Shield: Maintaining an active runway legally hard-codes FAA instrument approach and departure flight path height restrictions over the surrounding San Gorgonio Pass corridors. Eliminating this asset permanently strips these safety buffers, allowing high-density, massive industrial vertical footprints to encroach closer to residential boundaries without federal protection, possibly creating an unaudited infrastructure, traffic, and diesel-emission strain on surrounding neighborhoods during an already severe regional El Niño weather cycle.
  1. Documented Consequences of Pass-Area Logistics Over-Development: In evaluating the potential community benefit of a 3.2-million-square-foot warehouse expansion, this Council might possibly look closely at the real-world operational backlash occurring now across the San Gorgonio Pass. In neighboring Beaumont, aggressive logistical zoning has triggered reported severe community strain, resulting in documented diesel truck gridlock along the Interstate 10 corridor, accelerating localized road surface deterioration, and eroding the quiet enjoyment of residential zones. This regional friction has grown so acute that local planning commissions have actively begun issuing opposition votes against further warehouse projects due to the unmitigated cumulative impact on local air quality and quality of life. Furthermore, eliminating an active runway does not merely change the use of the 232 acres; it systematically removes the federal safety height caps that protect the wider community. Without the FAA instrument buffers, should multi-story industrial footprints expand vertically without federal aviation oversight, the resulting visual walling of the Pass, coupled with continuous heavy-freight traffic congestion, risks permanently depressing surrounding residential property values and creating structural traffic delays for Banning's families.
  1. We volunteer these observations to assist this body in performing its essential due diligence, that we know it cares to be respected for. We urge you to pause this vote until these critical public safety and quality-of-life impacts can be evaluated through a transparent, independent, and comprehensive regional study.

 

Respectfully submitted,

 

Ron Berinstein,

Director, Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG)

Email: contactus@scauwg.org

SANTA MONICA – REGIONAL POLICY ALERT / NOTICE OF LIABILITY

 

10/15/2026

====================================================================

REGIONAL POLICY ALERT / NOTICE OF LIABILITY

====================================================================

ISSUED BY:    The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG)

DATE:         October 15, 2026

DISTRIBUTION: Executive Office of the City Manager, Honorable Mayor,  and Members of the Santa Monica City Council

====================================================================

 

Dear City Manager Oliver Chi, Honorable Mayor Caroline Torosis, and Members of the City Council:

The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG) is issuing this formal policy alert and notice of administrative liability regarding the planned decommissioning of Santa Monica Airport (KSMO). As you move forward with the October 17th master plan presentation, this legislative body is being placed on the public record regarding the massive legal, financial, and risk-management liabilities confronting your offices.

  • The Upgraded FAA Stance: The Federal Enforcement Precedent

 Your administrative strategy relies on the outdated premise that local closure timelines are immune to changing federal enforcement priorities. The federal landscape has fundamentally shifted. Per Federal Register Doc. 2026-20859, the FAA Associate Administrator for Airports has officially established that federal policy mandates the retention of aviation assets to advance public safety, law enforcement, and emerging advanced air mobility technologies. On October 9, 2026, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) officially rescinded its prior approval for the permanent closure of the Indianapolis Downtown Heliport, effectively halting a high-profile municipal commercial redevelopment project. Federal supremacy is actively freezing local airport decommissioning plays across the United States.

  • The Revenue Diversion Blurry Accounting: A Documented Bad-Faith Record

 Your legal exposure is already severely compounded by active federal non-compliance findings. As ruled in the December 22, 2025 FAA Director’s Determination under Grant Assurance 25, issued by Director Michael Helvey, the city stands in active federal non-compliance. The city was officially caught manipulating its aeronautical fee schedules to illegally stockpile an estimated $19 million airport revenue surplus with the explicit intent to siphon those funds into general municipal services following a potential runway closure. This active compliance order remains an un-expired public record of administrative bad faith, which national aviation interests are currently leveraging to petition the federal government to invalidate the 2017 Consent Decree entirely.

  • Premature Economic Strangulation and Arbitrary Flight School CapsWhile the 2017 Consent Decree outlines a potential closure timeline at the conclusion of 2028, the City of Santa Monica remains legally bound by federal administrative law every single day the runway remains active. Under FAA Order 5190.6B, the city is strictly prohibited from executing a pre-closure strategy of economic containment or unjust discrimination against public airspace users.

The public record reveals an alleged highly calculated, artificial strangulation of airport commerce designed to manufacture a false narrative of economic decline. Mirroring the exact regulatory overreach currently being litigated in state court at Torrance Airport (KTOA), Santa Monica implemented a restrictive administrative cap limiting active flight schools to a maximum of six. The operational mechanics of this cap are a matter of public record: had the city not spent $450,000 in public taxpayer funds to allegedly evict Joe Justice and force Justice Aviation to cease operations after 25 years of pristine service, modern newcomers like Sling Pilot Academy would have been legally blocked from establishing their new campus. The city is weaponizing a rolling moratorium to prevent the aviation industry from naturally scaling, directly violating FAA Grant Assurance 22 (Economic Nondiscrimination) and Grant Assurance 23 (Exclusive Rights) prior to the legal 2028 boundary.

  • The Westside Isolation Trap: Financial Liability for Broken Mutual Aid

 Your push to replace a concrete runway with park sketches completely ignores the immediate physical survival and fiscal metrics of the Westside. Following the intense October 2026 heatwave, the current climate shift has triggered immediate coastal flooding and high surf, underscoring the fragility of our regional corridors. The California Geological Survey's active regulatory maps verify that the Santa Monica Fault Zone cuts directly across your urban corridors, leaving the Westside vulnerable to complete physical isolation when an earthquake shatters overpasses and buckles surface streets.

When the ground fails, survival comes from the air. KSMO represents the Westside’s only flat, non-structural mesa infrastructure capable of landing heavy C-130 relief aircraft and staging regional aerial firefighting assets. By willfully moving to demolish this runway, Santa Monica's leadership is deliberately breaking from the core principles of regional reciprocity underlying the California Master Mutual Aid Agreement. You are permanently destroying an irreplaceable asset, rendering your population entirely dependent on external Los Angeles City and County resources.

Be advised: neighboring jurisdictions and LA taxpayers are under no obligation to permanently subsidize the self-inflicted infrastructure liquidations of a wealthy coastal enclave. While initial mutual aid responses provide short-term relief, any extended extra-jurisdictional deployment of specialized aerial assets and emergency routing into an isolated Santa Monica might possibly result in staggering, non-reimbursable financial invoices billable directly to Santa Monica’s treasury. Paving over this runway does not eliminate disaster risk; it guarantees a possible multi-million-dollar emergency debt burden that Santa Monica taxpayers will carry for generations.

  • The Concrete Real Estate Precedent and Internal Litigation

 The narrative that this property will remain a permanent, open-space park is an economic and historical illusion. The historical precedent of Hughes Airport remains an undeniable warning: despite early promises of open space, the runway was paved over to become the high-density commercial and residential sprawl of Playa Vista due to municipal deficits and state housing mandates.

Furthermore, your internal closure coalition is actively collapsing into litigation. To meet basic consent decree parameters, the city was forced to bring commercial flights to the field via JSX turboprops. Today, your own anti-airport neighbors (Measure LC Defense) are actively suing the city in Los Angeles Superior Court over environmental review bypasses, maybe paralyzing your presentation timelines. True environmental justice requires managing your own regional footprint, not practicing environmental colonialism by outsourcing your corporate flight volumes and emergency dependencies to the neighborhoods surrounding Long Beach and Compton.

With independent FM3 Research polling proving that 67% of local voters favor keeping this field open, SCAUWG.ORG strongly advises this council to pause all decommissioning frameworks, realign with your federal statutory obligations, and protect KSMO as an unassailable public safety lifeline.

 

Respectfully submitted,

Ron Berinstein, Director. The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG)

"We Make Safety and Airport Advocacy Happen"

Visited by Thousands Weekly

About Whiteman Airport – a response to “Community Members React to Latest Local Plane Accident Out of Whiteman Airport” – (San Fernando Sun/el sol)

Comments:
1. Whiteman Airport was there since the forties. Everyone surrounding it located there later by their choice. LA City Zoning regulations deemed it safe. Everyone buying property near the airport had to sign escrow papers SAYING THAT THEY KNEW THERE WAS AN AIRPORT NEARBY!

2. Airports by law cannot, and do not control pilot qualifications. Those are federal matters. Should that not be the case, Monica Rodriquez could argue to close city owned Van Nuys Airport, as Van Nuys has had many, many, more accidents associated with it than Whiteman.

3. How about LAX? Should nearby residents propose closing LAX because an Alaska Airlines jet crashed while preparing to land and everyone on board was killed? Edwards AFB? Should it close because a B-52 just crashed killing 8? Should Reagan International close because of the recent helicopter / jet accident?

4. There are hundreds of car accidents on our freeways and roads daily nearby Pacoima. Should San Fernando Road and the nearby freeways with the cars and trucks that emit pollution, and have homes and businesses on both sides of them, cease operations immediately pending studies?

5. Residents know this: Should the airport close, imposing a tremendous overload and congestion for at least two other local airports, and possibly flight delays, and certainly delayed emergency firefighting responses, the associated redeveloped land use will most certainly turn public land to private-for-profit enterprise, and cause area residents to face higher rents and receive eviction notices, and be forced to relocate in order to accommodate new construction.

6. LA County has seen fit to allocate over one million dollars composed of community social fund monies, combined with airport revenue and other funds to study land use for an airport necessary for area emergency service and already given the FAA benefit of perpetuity, and special airport reliever status.

7. Supervisor Horvath says she supports improving local fire response service and advocates for an improved Whiteman airport, yet for years she has denied funding for Whiteman. Additionally, LA County sends Whiteman revenue to at least two other County owned airports starving Whiteman of its own revenue.

8. It’s time that our politicians start actually representing what is truly good for our communities, and not what may be good for the pocketbooks of certain special interests.

9. The helicopter base chief has said Whiteman is necessary for them to provide efficient response. The devastating fires were fought by helicopters from Whiteman. The Sandy fire was fought by Whiteman Helicopter first responders. Search and Rescue is headquartered there, Thousands of free rides for community children have been made available from there.

10. Whiteman Airport needs to stay public. Low-income housing can be built elsewhere, thus protecting the area residents from strain on natural resources and the resulting traffic congestion

 

The entire article as published can be read via this link:

Community Members React to Latest Local Plane Accident Out of Whiteman Airport

Santa Monica City Council May 12TH AIRPORT ISSUE MTG. & VIDEO

SCAUWG.ORG

The SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA AVIATION UNITED WORKING GROUP

We Make Safety Happen!

 

05/12/2026   NBC-TV   VIDEO Coverage of Santa Monica City Council  5/12/26 - Airport Agenda Item:            

By report approximately 250 people in favor of the airport were present at the overflowing, packed, meeting, Though the vast majority in the room were Pro-Airport, featured presenting to the council were three anti-airport voices, and one pro-airport speaker.  One anti-airport voice said she can't talk on the phone and do work, another said she can't work, and apparently without knowing that unleaded fuel is available at the airport, reading from a prepared speech, she spoke about how her property was a dumping ground for leaded fuel, and that she can't work. The third complained that her air purifier turns yellow and red.  The pro-airport featured speaker expressed that without the airport staying open LAX could send their traffic over SMO.

No reference was reported as to whether the residential areas referred to are zoned for work.  No interviews with the anti-airport voices were included asking if i they knew that the 103-year-old airport (the second oldest airport continuously in operation in the United States) was there prior to them moving into the area, and if property owners, they signed escrow papers acknowledging the airport's location. Nor was it indicated if any of the anti-airport speakers were hesitant to go to someone else's neighborhood, like those surrounding LAX, Hollywood Burbank & Ontario, and fly really large aircraft at their desire, and whether they considered it okay to allegedly impose on those area residents.

Welcomed is that NBC-TV covered the meeting and interviewed a few airport supporters. Stressed was that SMO is Santa Monica's "community's airport," that there is now passenger service to several cities, and that Santa Monica Airport provided very important emergency services while fighting the recent devastating fires.   One voiced that the City cannot afford making the property a Park, and that there was a very good possibility that (inferring reference to past examples) the final result would NOT be a Park.  The aviation supporters desire that there be another city-wide vote to determine the airport's future, they represented that the result would reflect a recent survey's determination that 67% of Santa Monica residents want the airport to stay open in some form.

You can view the NBC-TV Coverage Here.

 

Contact: Ron Berinstein     E mail: Contactus@Scauwg.org

Open Letter to KTLA News

Submitted feedback for the KTLA 5 Programming Department 

re: Pacoima residents call for Whiteman Airport closure following small plane crash - Here

RE: Pacoima Aircraft Accident - 4/21/2026

1. Charged: Residents want it closed – The truth: EVERY nearby Neighborhood council has voted to support the airport by a very wide margin. The representation that RESIDENTS want it closed is flawed.  Neighborhood surveys overwhelmingly confirm the pro-airport sentiment.

2. Charged: Monica Rodriquez was reported to claim the LA County airport is mismanaged (by LA County) inferring that a federally certificated accident pilot who intended to land there was the airport’s fault, and the airport should be closed. Yet, the thousands of car accidents in LA City don’t suggest that nearby freeways and streets should be closed.  Blaming the airport is like blaming the big box store should it be robbed.

3. Charged: LA County mismanages the FEDERALLY REGULATED airport and Airspace operations. Truth: LA County manages the facilities and should do a better job, but they are not responsible for approving certificated pilots.

4. City Councilmember Monica Rodriquez represents the city whose zoning dept. allowed development near the airport, there since the forties. Also, true – Property owners and residents chose to reside near the airport.

5. Whiteman airport played an important role saving lives and property during the LA Fires. Barton Heliport’s Chief is on record saying that efficient operation depends upon the airport being open supporting the airport tower’s role.

6. Besides the emergency services offered, Angel Flight, the CAP Search and Rescue Ops, Air Explorers, EAA & many other community services also find their home at Whiteman. KTLA’s helicopter I believe find its home is Whiteman as well!

7. Whiteman Airport provides revenue that keeps two other L A County airports open that otherwise would have to close.

8. Whiteman Airport is a FEDERAL RELIEVER AIRPORT and plays an important role in the National Airspace System (NAS).

9. Whiteman Airport should not have to endure closure demands allegedly motivated by those with the desire for fiscally profitable redevelopment interests. KTLA should not be a pawn in that game!

10. Whiteman Airport benefits from FEDERAL PERPETUITY that regulates the airport’s undisturbed longevity into the future because of an LA County real estate purchase in 1998. 11. There is much more that can be said…e.g. The recent FAA letter to LA County OED confirming “Perpetuity” and regardless of that advice the OED has allocated a reported 1.5 million dollars for use for a land use study. Redevelopment Interests exist on both the City’s and on the County’s part.

Bottom line: Should the airport close, apx. 400 aircraft would have to relocate. Van Nuys general aviation airport is nearby. Monica Rodriquez would be happy, but Councilmember Imelda Padilla, whose district includes VAN NUYS Airport, would not be! Whereas the very vast majority of Pacoima Residents support the airport that even provides free airplane rides for kids monthly, the residents of Van Nuys area (who also support Whiteman) definitely do not support expanding Van Nuys Airport and would be up in arms!

Respectfully,
Ron Berinstein, Director, The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG)

What is the Whiteman Airport Land Use Study Release Date?

4/11/2026 The Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG) Editorial: Regarding the yet unknown Trifiletti Whiteman Airport Land Use Study release date. It should be noted that the Office of Economic Development (OED) just tendered $200,000.00 in addition to the original $1.3 million cost, to per an informed source’s recent published report extend the release date until after the June 2026 elections. This was described as time to allow for MORE community engagement. That may be questionable.

One might ask if the study results have already been foreshadowed, and if the sponsors of the study, who have well voiced their anti-airport bias, feel they need more time and another chance to try and change the already well established pro-airport community position, and save those sponsor’s and their campaign fueled by misinformation, from public embarrassment. So as to avoid continued debate, we hope that the Trifiletti study will accurately describe the majority of community opinion, as well as the facts already agreed to over two decades ago by LA County and the FAA via regulations. That agreement included the benefit of perpetuity for the airport, and dictates the land use must be maintained for aviation. FAA precedent has upheld these types of agreements. It would truly be unfortunate if allowing an important public resource recently used for emergency services and fighting the LA Fires, to be transformed into a non-aviation commercial private development.

SCAUWG.ORG Response – Is Whiteman Airport in Compliance With Federal Regulations? published 4/9/26 by LACP

Editor,

Some of the points mentioned published regarding Whiteman Airport by LACP on 4/9/2026 require further investigation. For example, LA County is the current recipient of a Part 16 complaint (FAA Docket No. 16-24-14). Subject: Incorrect tenant rents.  At one County airport the Assessor's office is alleged to be using a, "Light Manufacturing Code" to bill tenants, as opposed to the County code for "T-Hangers." If a parent abuses a child, the child should not be further punished, rather the parenting should be improved. Should this not be the case, pdeARarent governments could just avoid their legal responsibility and then use the poor resultant as the reason to divest themselves of that responsibility.

Whiteman brings in more revenue than any other County airport!  That revenue though does NOT stay at the airport!  The County sends a partial amount to other County airports!  While not illegal, WITHOUT that funding, informed opinion is that two other County airports would be forced to close!  Are additional funds available for Whiteman to make associated improvements besides the actual airport income? Yes, and as an example of curtailing funding for Whiteman, the airport that was so important as a provider of emergency services during the LA Fires, it was published on March 4, 2024, by the then BOS Chair on her own website that "...the County will not seek future funding from the FAA that would further lengthen aviation operations at Whiteman Airport, a measure that is also in alignment with her November 7 motion on the future of the 78-year-old airport."  At that time a minimum of 90% of a project cost could be applied for, and accepting the federal funds would NOT extend operations at the airport, This, because of a County land purchase and the already agreed to benefit of perpetuity for Whiteman, a point reiterated and made clear in the public record, and addressed to the BOS on October 21, 2024 when the Board voted to spend 1.3 million dollars on a repurposing STUDY. Subsequently, another $200,000 has been allocated for the same purpose. Accepting FAA grant money was also opposed by a local grant-funded group who prefers to close the Whiteman airport in favor of private redevelopment and the resulting area congestion, and no doubt, gentrification, and the exodus of so many current residents due to economic injustice.

Open Letter to Santa Monica City Councilmembers – Prosper or Park

OPEN LETTER TO SANTA MONICA CITY COUNCILMEMBERS - PROSPER or PARK

Seize the moment - Don’t Ignore Opportunity

Maintain Santa Monica Airport

Dear Councilmembers,

When Starbucks had to close stores (3) in Santa Monica, if it didn’t send a message to all, it should.

I strongly support keeping the Santa Monica Airport open while exploring ways to expand park space and community benefits.

You have an opportunity to market your hotel, local businesses, restaurants, and your convention center.

YOUR OCEAN VIEW AND THE PIER should be promoted and the airport can make it easy for folks with money to arrive at Santa Monica without the congestion of LAX and spend their money IN SANTA MONICA whilst enjoying the ocean view from their hotel suites, the beach opportunities you create, the dining, and their sightseeing.

Maybe you think that's a silly notion.  But look at the Hotel Del Coronado.  A few years ago, it was just a mismanaged historic venture for tourists. NOW, Hilton has turned the tables selling their beach options and the dining at every price level. WHY can they do that with a thousand dollars a night accommodation?  THE OCEAN VIEW and innovative ideas.  Certainly, not the hotel amenities themselves.

The Smart money says create sightseeing at the airport.  Pilot groups will no doubt volunteer to help restore the rich heritage there (like the original Del Building) - Market the available great businesses, and via innovation (just look at what Hilton did with minimal expense and thousands of twinkle lights at the Del) design benefits from the Ocean Environment.

MARKET your opportunities! Sell the convenience of an executive airport concierge transportation service, and the accented historic references, to corporations that can use your convention space, or your hotel options, and that can reward their employees, or their clients, with a great experience.

Of course. you can destroy those options. You can ignore opportunities, do nothing for your community business, and do nothing to restore Santa Monica's profitable presence.

A park-only option creates enormous costs for the City at a time when Santa Monica is already facing serious budget challenges.

Most importantly, a strong majority of Santa Monica voters support keeping the airport while still having park space and businesses. I hope the City will take the time to pursue balanced solutions that preserve this important community resource while adding new public space and amenities.

Please listen to residents and avoid rushing toward closing the airport.  This, particularly now with eVtol service pending, and commercial air service already in place.

Thank you for your service to our community.

Sincerely,
Ron Berinstein, Director
Southern California Aviation United Working Group (SCAUWG.ORG)

 

Addressing SMO & the December 2025 FAA Decision

01/02/2026 Special to SCAUWG.ORG – OPINION – from Matthew Stone (Addressing the December 2025 FAA decision)

The political whirlwinds around Santa Monica Airport have whipped for many decades and it is clear that 2026 will continue this trend. The airport, reputedly facing closure within a few short years, has not been allowed any peace in its supposed twilight.

In 2017, litigation between the City of Santa Monica and FAA was settled with a Consent Decree which allowed the city to close Santa Monica Airport on December 31, 2028 while honoring aviation obligations as operations sunset. It is now clear that City officials have not honored the standing agreements the 2017 deal was built upon.

In light of the recent Federal Aviation Administration ruling that the City of Santa Monica has violated federal law by improperly accumulating a $19 million non-aeronautical surplus through manipulative fee structures—contravening Grant Assurance 25 and 49 U.S.C. § 47133—it is evident that the city has acted in clear bad faith. This violation, involving the separation of revenues and a drastic 53% reduction in aeronautical rates to preserve funds for non-airport uses post-closure, undermines the integrity of federal grant obligations and the 2017 Consent Decree itself.

I urge the FAA to seek an annulment of this Consent Decree and a revocation of the closure allowance on the basis of city officials’ noncompliance. Santa Monica officials reneged on their part of the bargain and even tried to argue with the FAA about matters under federal authorities’ jurisdiction.

Area residents also have good reason to smother closure efforts given the realistic futures facing the airport’s land. The original sales pitch for a “grand park” has faded as developers have come out of the woodwork to press their agendas. Voters were sold on the park as the ‘only’ future for Santa Monica Airport’s land…but now it’s clear special interests hope to push their agenda in at the eleventh hour. As the City engages in shady funding methods that violate federal guidelines, voters have no reason to believe their wishes will be honored either.

For the sake of accountability and to encourage good governance, punitive action by federal authorities against the City of Santa Monica is warranted to protect national interests and ensure compliance with aviation law. An annulment of the 2017 Consent Decree is an excellent place to start, regardless of whether Santa Monica officials threaten further litigation.  – MS