To: LA County PW
To whom it May Concern:
I speak on behalf of numerous KEMT hangar tenants. There are some concerns regarding the County’s attempt to pass the burden of maintaining the County owned hangar structures to the tenants that have only month-to-month license agreements, and who use the County’s hangar facilities for storing aircraft.
Contrary to the old agreements with American Airport Corporation; some still in effect, the new hanger license agreements require the tenant to inspect the hangar unit and accept the hangar "as is" as of the date of signing the contract agreement. However, there is no specific language that the month-to-month hangar tenant is required to provide repairs and maintenance to the County facilities, such as a leaking roof, accept in cases where the tenant causes the damage.
In my case, the roof did not leak when I signed my contract, nor did it leak in subsequent rainstorms. However, water streaming onto my light switch and electrical outlet is a new event due to the recent rains and the progressive failure of the roof structure to prevent water intrusion. The exact same condition applies to a nearby hangar. In that case, water began dripping onto a classic aircraft, as well as onto the entry light switch/electrical outlet.
Consequently, I would like to suggest that comments made by LA COUNTY PW that infers my license agreement relieves the County of structural maintenance obligations is misguided. Nowhere does the contract state that a month-to-month licensee is responsible for structural repairs due to a decline in facility due to poor construction, old age, non-tenant related criminal behavior, or an act of God.
Other LAC commercial leases explicitly state where the long-term commercial tenant might be responsible for maintaining the structure, such as tenants with ground leases. But for month-to-month license tenants, the idea that the tenant is responsible for maintaining the County’s property, while the County retains complete control over repairs and maintenance (as stated in the license agreements) is an over-reach, and would place undue burden on the tenant. The month-to-month licensee tenants do not own a leasehold and thereby lack control over the ownership of the hangar structure.
Additionally, hangar tenants pay a Possessory Interest Tax for use of the hangar, as well as a property tax on their aircraft. I would like to further address the PI tax and the liability issues:
- Valuation & Improvements: As noted by the Napa County Assessor's Office, a PI tax is assessed solely on the market value of the right to possess the land and improvements for that anticipated term. If a hangar's roof fails and renders the space unusable or degraded, the actual market value of that possessory right drops—which is grounds for an assessment appeal with the Los Angeles County Assessment Appeals Board
Why Structural & Roof Repairs Belong to the County
In standard County-owned T-hangar or box hangar agreements (managed by Los Angeles County Public Works), maintenance duties are strictly divided:
- Lessor (County) Responsibility: Structural integrity (roof, walls, foundation), exterior surfaces, common ramps, and main hangar door tracks/frames.
- Lessee (Tenant) Responsibility: Interior cleanliness, light bulbs, minor door lubrication, and damage caused by the tenant's own negligence.
Why shifting structural repairs to a month-to-month tenant might defy legal and financial logic:
- Lack of Capital Amortization: In commercial real estate, structural maintenance is only shifted to a tenant under a long-term "Triple Net" (NNN) lease (typically 10 to 50 years under California Government Code § 50478), allowing the tenant time to amortize major capital repairs. Requiring a 30-day tenant to pay for a roof repair allows the County to accept a capital improvement and immediately terminate the lease the following month.
- Prohibition on Structural Alterations: Standard airport leases strictly forbid tenants from penetrating the roof or making structural modifications without written engineering approval and permits. A tenant cannot legally be held financially responsible for maintaining a structure they are barred from altering or repairing themselves.
- Constructive Eviction & Habitability/Fitness: While residential "implied warranty of habitability" laws do not automatically apply to commercial hangars, California commercial lease law still recognizes constructive eviction and breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment. If a leaking roof damages an airworthy aircraft or prevents the hangar from being used for its sole permitted purpose (aircraft storage), the County is failing to deliver the contracted premises.
At San Gabriel Valley Airport (EMT), LA County Public Works (LADPW) perhaps cannot legally or logically trap a month-to-month tenant in a "catch-22" where the tenant is barred from repairing a structural roof leak yet forced to bear the financial or physical burden of the failure—especially when water intrusion into a live electrical switch creates an immediate fire and life-safety code violation.
Because the lease is direct with LADPW several distinct legal, regulatory, and contractual failures may be at play here.
- The Contractual "Catch-22" & Implied Covenant
While California commercial leases do not carry the residential "implied warranty of habitability" under California Civil Code § 1941, an "As-Is" clause only waives defects existing at the time the lease was signed (or visible upon inspection). I believe It does not absolve a landlord of structural maintenance when the contract simultaneously strips the tenant of the right to make repairs.
- Impossible Performance: I believe under California contract law, if a landlord retains exclusive control over the exterior shell and roof—and explicitly prohibits the tenant from making structural repairs—the duty to maintain that roof remains with the landlord by necessity.
- Breach of Quiet Enjoyment: I think under California Civil Code § 1927, every commercial lease carries an implied covenant of quiet enjoyment. When LADPW's failure to maintain a County-owned roof allows water to damage the hangars interior content or aircraft it might create an unsafe or costly circumstance.
- The Electrical Hazard Overrides the Lease:
Water entering a wall-mounted electrical switch is no longer a simple maintenance dispute; it is an active California Electrical Code (CEC) and Fire Code violation on County-owned property, and I know that neither you nor I want that.
- Non-Delegable Safety Duty: A public entity should not be able to use an "As-Is" clause to contract away its duty to abate an activhazard in a building it owns and controls.
- Immediate Liability Exposure: I would like to suggest that as the on-site management is now aware that water is entering an energized junction box or switch, that I am very thankful that LA COUNTY PW will quickly take action as the the circuit and the leaky roof exposes the County to premises liability should a fire destroy multiple aircraft in the hangar row.
Possessory Interest (PI) Tax Contradiction:
A major inconsistency in the County's position:
- Taxed on Functional Value: The LA County Assessor taxes the tenant based on the fair market value of an intact, weather-tight aircraft hangar over an assumed multi-year term.
- Calamity / Decline-in-Value Relief: My Goal is simply to have the hangar repaired. It is not my goal to see the County PW insist the hangar is "as-is" with a failing structure. No one wants to have to file an Assessment Appeal with the Los Angeles County Assessment Appeals Board for a Decline-in-Value (Prop 8) reduction, arguing the possessory interest has been impaired by unaddressed structural dilapidation.
FAA Grant Assurances (Sponsor Maintenance Obligations):
Because EMT is a federally obligated public-use airport, LA County might be bound by FAA Grant Assurance 19 (Operation and Maintenance).
- Even if hangars are revenue-generating facilities rather than airfield pavement, the FAA requires airport sponsors to maintain airport facilities in a safe, serviceable condition and prohibits sponsors from letting revenue-producing aeronautical facilities deteriorate into safety hazards while collecting market-rate rents (which LADPW recently benchmarked in its EMT Aeronautical Airport Rent Study).
I respectfully request the county engage tenants who request repairs to failing County hangars and perform the necessary repairs in order to maintain serviceable hangar inventory. I met with a County representative yesterday and was offered two items:
Item 1. Truly, I was offered to move and relocate to another hangar, however, there is no other similar size hangar available. Sat that moment I suggested doing so would prevent a revenue producing hangar from being leased. That wouldn’t be good. I declined the offer as this would not be prudent real estate management, it would neither fix the problem, nor could I enjoy the same amenities of my current hangar, as is my goal.
Item 2. It was then offered to try and abate the water contact on the light switch/outlet. I agreed and appreciated the proposed partial remedy. However, this does not abate the leaks in other areas of the hangar.
I propose that the County provide a remedy to repair any leaking hangars upon the request of the affected tenants. I am sure that no one, neither the County PW nor the tenants, want leaky roofs.
Thank you,